Theatre Review | A Beautiful Noise

A Beautiful Noise Music and Lyrics: Neil Diamond
Book: Neil McCarten
Director Michael Mayer
Lyric Theatre until February 14
Photo credit: Jeff Busby
Reviewed by Ron Lee, CSP

A shy, Jewish boy in Brooklyn, New York, became a global giant in the music industry and now, at age 85, is unable to perform, A Beautiful Noise is a musical about the life and career of Neil Diamond.
In 1966, the struggling songwriter hung out at New York’s legendary Brill Building where he tried to get the attention of the highly successful song writer and music producer Ellie Greenwich who was responsible for such hits as “Da Doo Ron Ron”, “Be My Baby”, “Then He Kissed Me”, “River Deep-Mountain High”, “Chapel of Love”, “I Can Hear Music”, “Leader of the Pack”, “Tell Laura I Love Her” and a multitude of others. How many of those songs went through your head as you read the titles?
Neil Diamond persistently played his songs for Greenwich without success until he came up with “I’m a Believer” which The Monkees recorded and it became a global smash hit.
When it was suggested that Neil should perform his own songs, he was hesitant and nervous, but when you get the bug that metamorphoses into endless waves of adrenalin rushes, there’s no stopping you.

Neil Diamond rose to the crest of that tide when wrote Sweet Caroline in a thirty minutes. Act one of the show concludes with his realisation that stardom was to be part of his destiny.
Act Two opens in full-blown concert mode with a nine-piece band that sounds much bigger. With total confidence he interacts with the audience and sports that Hot August Night hair.
The show has twenty-nine songs that include, “Cherry, Cherry”, “Crackling’ Rosie”, “America”, “Forever in Blue Jeans”, “Holly Holy”, “I’m A Believer”, “Crunchy Granola Suite”, “I Am…I Said”, “Kentucky Woman”, “Play Me”, “You Don’t Bring Me Flowers”, “Solitary Man”, “Shilo”, “Love On The Rocks”, “Red, Red Wine” and of course, “A Beautiful Noise” and “Sweet Caroline”. Each of the songs holds a deep meaning for its creator.
The ascension from shy songwriter to international star caused stresses and strains on his first two marriages and his children. Pursuing your passion, purpose and dreams in life is sometimes impossible to resist, and family relationships pay a price.
The part of Neil Diamond’s life that was omitted from the production was his relationship with Rae Farley, a Sydney-based promotions agent whom he met on his 1996 Australian tour. The two had a personal and professional relationship for thirteen years and it ended acrimoniously.
The performance opens with the Doctor interviewing octogenarian Neil Diamond whose health now renders him unable to perform, and the Doctor prompts him to reflect on his life. Doctor is played by Australian-born-Chinese actor, Monica Sayers. It’s gratifying to see an Asian actor cast in a non-racially-specific role. Newcastle’s Terence Crawford is Neil Now who anchors the story, and his solo near the end provides a delightful surprise.
Alana Tranter as first wife Jaye Posner, Ashleigh Rubenach as second wife Marcia Murphey and Hannah Frederickson as Ellie Greenwich are experienced and talented triple threats who provide powerful support as Neil’s muses. In fact, the entire cast of twenty-five is strong.
So what about Will Swenson as the young Neil?
The hugely talented, Utah-born performer has an impressive list of musical theatre credits that include the leads in American productions of Miss Saigon, Sweeney Todd and Jekyll & Hyde. He also played he Pirate King in The Pirates of Penzance, Javert in Les Miz, Frank N Furter in The Rocky Horror Show, Berger in Hair, Mitzi in Priscilla, Queen of The Desert and Neil Then in the Boston and Broadway productions of A Beautiful Noise as well as a long list of theatre, film and television appearances.

A Beautiful Noise at the Lyric Theatre provides an uplifting, feel-good experience that is contemporaneously reflective on a life that has had its share of towering highs, depressive lows and several regrets. Fortunately, the elements of his life that stand out for us are the songs.
There’s no need to tell you about the finale except that you will be standing like everyone else in the audience, singing along and yelling the responses.
A Beautiful Noise is a must-see show and you’ll walk out of the theatre smiling and singing - guaranteed.
Discover more of Ron's Theatre Reviews in Sydney.
.png)



